5 Comfiest Pillow Top Mattresses in 2018 – Reviews and Buying Guide

An average man will spend about 229,961 hours of his life sleeping, provided that each person sleeps for 8 hours per day. That’s one-third of the life of an average person, and you don’t want to spend one-third of your life sleeping in discomfort, right? Of course, nobody wants that, which is why it is very important for you to choose a high-quality mattress. In other words, you need a mattress that offers optimum comfort and cloud-like sleeping feeling, and no other mattress type provides those better than pillow top mattresses. With the best pillow top mattress, your nights and health are guaranteed to become better.

Pillow top mattresses come with several benefits such as comfort, pain relief, longevity, motion isolation, support, and a lot more. Originally, sleeping on a pillow top mattress bolsters optimal comfort. Having considered all the benefits offered by pillow top mattresses, we consequently chose to make a guide about the best pillow-top mattresses on the market. In our guide, we considered important factors such as materials used (springs, memory foam, latex), thickness, number of layers, firmness, and most suitable sleep positions, amongst several other factors which we will talk about later.

Top 5 Pillow Top Mattresses Review 2018

Below, you will find a comparison table in which our picks are extensively highlighted, as well as comprehensive reviews of the pillow top mattresses we chose. Also, you should make sure to read our handy buying guide which contains everything you need to know about the various considerations and features that are needed to choose the best pillow top mattress.

Name and Features Image Rating Price
1. Zinus Ultima Comfort 10-inch Pillow Top Spring Mattress (Editor’s Choice)
Quilted with luxurious jacquard fabric, this pillow top mattress contains four layers for superior comfort and body pressure relief
Zinus Ultima Comfort 10 Inch Pillow Top Spring Mattress
2. Signature Sleep 13-inch Pillow-Top Mattress (Most Breathable)
The thickest model on the list that is comprised of 630 coils and several layers of high density support foam will let you get a good night’s sleep without any motion transfer
Signature Sleep 13 inch Pillow-Top Mattress
3. Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top 12-inch Mattress (Most Hypoallergenic)
A great mattress made by a trusted manufacturer will keep you away from germs, bacteria, and dust particles
Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top 12-Inch Mattress
4. Classic Brands Pillow Top 10-inch Mattress (Best for Back Pain)
Consisting of 792 individually wrapped coils this model provides you with a proper spinal alignment and weight distribution
Classic Brands Pillow Top 10-Inch Mattress
5. Swiss Ortho Sleep 12-inch Plush Pillow Top (Budget Pick)
Despite of an affordable price this pick doesn’t compromise quality, breathable and hypoallergenic soft bamboo fiber cover also gives you extra peace of mind
Swiss Ortho Sleep 12 inch Plush Pillow Top
Features
  • Mattress type: hybrid – comfort foam + springs
  • Pillow top: memory foam, quilted with jacquard fabric
  • Thickness: 10 inches
  • Number of layers: 4
  • Firmness: firm
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US
  • Warranty: 10-year limited

Extra features: contains natural green tea extract

OVERALL RATING: 9.4 out of 10

The Zinus Ultima Comfort 10-Inch Pillow Top Mattress is one of the most affordable pillow top mattresses available on the market. Fortunately, the lower cost doesn’t compromise quality. This pillow top mattress has great support, which is tailored to relieve your body pressure. The mattress also provides alignment support. In general, this mattress is perfect for a restful night’s sleep.

The Zinus Ultima Comfort 10-Inch Pillow Top Mattress comes with an iCoil system that is made up of numerous independent coils. This system takes away every issue related to motion transfer. The pressure relieving comfort foam used to make this pillow top leaves you with an additional comfortable surface. Also, the springs add to the overall comfort, which helps relieve sleeper’s pain at night.

Furthermore, this pillow top mattress from Zinus comes with a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty for peaceful nights. It comes compressed, rolled, and can be shipped to your doorstep for optimum convenience. You can’t afford to miss the chance of owning this excellent pillow top mattress.

PROS:
  • Affordable price
  • Relieves body pressure

CONS:
  • Might be too firm for side sleepers

Features
  • Type: hybrid – memory foam + springs
  • Pillow top: memory foam, plush
  • Thickness: 13 inches
  • Number of layers: 4
  • Firmness: medium
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US
  • Warranty: 10-year limited

Extra features: coil count – 630

OVERALL RATING: 9.2 out of 10

Signature Sleep is another household name in the bedding industry, and yet again, they have come through with a high-quality mattress. This model is 13 inches thick and comes with a 10-inch layer of innerspring coils. The combination of springs and memory foam improves the comfort and firmness of this mattress. Also, it is one of the less expensive options to choose from, and it is recommended for individuals who don’t want any disturbance in their sleep as this pillow top mattress has no motion transfer.

The soft bamboo fiber cover provides natural moisture absorbency and breathability, which makes it a decent fit for warmer temperatures. There is a one-inch pillow top made of polyurethane foam underneath. The foam is divided into three zones: upper, middle, and lower. Both upper and lower zones offer more comfort to your legs and head, while the middle zone offers more resilience for sustaining your lower back since most of your weight is concentrated there.

Despite being relatively cheap, this mattress has CertiPUR-US certification, which means its foam doesn’t contain toxic chemicals that could affect you or your home adversely. With that being said, the cheap price means this mattress is not made for overweight individuals, which is obvious as there have been numerous complaints from users about it wearing out after just a few years fervent of usage.

PROS:
  • Very affordable
  • Great comfort and support for fairly short-term or lightweight use
  • CertiPUR-US® certified
  • Bamboo fiber cover allows breathability

CONS:
  • No trial period offered

Features
  • Mattress type: hybrid – innerspring + gel memory foam
  • Pillow top: quilted with a corded edge, cushion-firm
  • Thickness: 12 inches
  • Number of layers: 5
  • Firmness: medium
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US
  • Warranty: 10-year limited

Extra features: compressed, rolled and shipped in a box

OVERALL RATING: 9.1 out of 10

Classic Brands is one of the leading mattress manufacturing companies in the world, and their Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top 12-Inch Mattress shows why they have remained at the top of the game. The Mercer pillow top is a great mattress, which offers the ideal mix of supportive and soft. And with its very affordable price, you can’t bet against this mattress becoming one of the most popular mattresses in the world so soon.

The top of the mattress has a 12-inch gel foam cover. Under this layer there are four more layers to offer adequate support and comfort to the sleeper. In addition to that, this pillow top mattress gives more support with separately covered coils which improve its firmness. The mattress is also known for its ability to prevent different germs, bacteria, and dust particles from getting on it and reaching you.

The Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top Mattress itself has a medium firmness, which allows you to relish a soft but supportive mattress. The infused cool gel keeps your body from becoming too sweaty and warm. Apart from that, this mattress from Classic Brands provides your hips, sides, and back with support, so you don’t have body aches. The pillow top mattress comes with CertiPUR-US certification, which means that it has been tested for performance, durability, and doesn’t emit harmful chemicals.

PROS:
  • Thick foam layers
  • Stainless steel spring coils at the bottom tier
  • CertiPUR-US certified
  • Free of antimicrobials and allergens

CONS:
  • The smell of chemical lingers for a couple of days
  • Takes a while to expand to its full size

Features
  • Type: hybrid – comfort foam + springs
  • Pillow top: comfort foam, 1 inch
  • Thickness: 10 inches
  • Number of layers: 3
  • Firmness: medium-firm
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US
  • Warranty: 10-year limited

Extra features: consists of 792 individually wrapped coils

OVERALL RATING: 8.8 out of 10

Classic Brand is a company that actually needs no introduction, and many of you know their mattresses guaranteed quality. The Classic Brands Pillow Top 10-Inch Mattress is an excellent option for people in search of a medium-firm mattress that has a pillow top. Offering superior support due to its firmness, this model aids proper weight distribution and proper spinal alignment.

This pillow top mattress contains individually wrapped steel coils which restrict motion transfer to a minimum and are sturdier than regular innerspring mattresses have. For a unique feel, each of the inner springs move freely to one another. Most innerspring mattresses are often less expensive than foam mattresses, but that does not in any way mean you are giving up quality.

The Classic Brand mattress also comes with a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty for ease of mind. It is also compressed for easy shipping. In general, you can’t go wrong with this high-quality mattress from Classic Brand.

PROS:
  • Very affordable
  • Aids spinal alignment
  • Excellent weight distribution

CONS:
  • It doesn’t seem to be up to 10 inches as described

Features
  • Type: innerspring
  • Pillow top: memory foam, bamboo fabric
  • Thickness: 12 inches
  • Number of layers: 1
  • Firmness: plush
  • Certification: CertiPUR-US
  • Warranty: not specified

Extra features: non-toxic with flame retardant

OVERALL RATING: 8.7 out of 10

The Swiss Ortho 12-Inch Plush Pillow Top Mattress is an excellent choice if you’re in search of an affordable innerspring mattress. Despite being fairly cheap, it provides a decent quality of sleep, owing to the unique features utilized throughout it. This 12-inch model is packed with every attribute required to guarantee a peaceful sleep in a modest, but a beautiful mattress. The mattress comes with a soft bamboo fiber cover which is breathable and hypoallergenic, and alongside the independent coils make for a cool and comfortable sleeping surface. This mattress is perfect if you have a tendency of sleeping hot.

What’s more, the 13-gauge individual wrapped coils provide optimal support concentrated on the areas of your body that require it the most, while minimizing motion transfer. This makes the Swiss Ortho Pillow Top Mattress an excellent choice if you sleep with somebody else. The coil system has improved features when it comes to pressure relief and is proved to be great for better airflow and blood circulation in the mattress.

Furthermore, this mattress from Swiss Ortho has been structured in such a way that it is very resilient and durable, which explains why it comes with a 10-year manufacturer’s warranty. It is not a surprise that this mattress is one of Swiss Ortho’s bestselling products, as it provides optimum comfort and support, at a very affordable cost compared to its rivals.

PROS:
  • No motion transfer
  • Breathable sleep surface
  • Provides good value for money
  • Improved comfort and support

CONS:
  • You might start feeling the springs after a while

Buying Guide

Choosing the best pillow top mattress is not that easy as it might seem at first. There are so many features you need to take into consideration, that your shopping consequently becomes much more stressful. Luckily for you, in this section, we’ve collected everything that you need to know to find the best pillow top mattress.

What are the Advantages of Pillow Top Mattresses?

First things first, though, let us tell you about the advantages of pillow top mattresses over other types of mattresses.

Plush Comfort

Pillow Top Mattresses

This is what makes everyone fall in love with pillow-top mattresses. How relaxing does it feel to lay on bed packed with soft pillows? Yeah, you know that feeling! That is exactly the feeling a pillow top mattress will give you. The level of firmness varies from soft to firm and a few differences between these limits. All of them have the comfort attributes of hybrid and memory foam options.

Pain Relief

A high-quality pillow top mattress is capable of making a huge difference when it comes to easing stiffness and pain. If you suffer from some kind of pain, you will realize that the padded cushion provides superior contouring around your back and shoulders. Besides, there are some orthopedic solutions that ease the pain by removing the pressure from the whole body.

Good for Stomach and Side Sleepers

Both stomach and side sleepers will find the support offered by these mattresses really amazing. The top layer of the mattress contours around the body shape. You will, however, not get the orthopedic support level for the spinal adjustment. People suffering from lower back pain will not get any treatment.

Less Movement Transmission

The motion isolation is an excellent feature which is most useful when you’re sleeping with another person. There will be minimal circulation of vibrations when the person sleeping next to you tosses and turns. It limits movement owing to the thick layer of padding and the pocket coil design.

Features to Consider While Choosing a Pillow Top Mattress

It would be a very bad idea to place your focus on only the pillow top part when shopping for the right pillow top mattress. All the regular advice and rules surrounding purchase of conventional mattresses applies to a pillow top mattress as well. However, here is a couple of unique things you need to take into consideration when buying a pillow top mattress.

The man is lying on the mattress

Types of Mattress

The material utilized for the support segment affects the mattress’s structural properties. While spring mattresses usually offer great support, they may transfer movement much more than foam support layers.
Polyurethane foam is another type of a support layer, and such mattresses tend to be sturdier. They are usually softer and allow adequate air circulation, which, therefore, keeps your body cool.
The material has an effect on the mattress’s longevity as well. While latex usually offers the longest-lasting models, they are also the costliest. As for memory foam, the odds that it will deform permanently is also very small compared to less expensive materials.

The quality and type of the pillow layer are capable of having a huge impact on the general comfort. Memory foam contours perfectly to the shape of your body and offers great support.
Also, natural latex offers a receptive sleeping surface that does not cause extreme pressure on only one region. Besides, latex is usually cooler than other foam types.

Motion Transfer

While it is usually a trivial concern, how considerably a mattress stifles vibration should be also taken into consideration when deciding between two mattresses. It can also be vital if you sleep with someone else who often turns and tosses during the night, and thereby risks waking you up if the bed beneath you shakes.

Hybrid mattresses containing foam tend to be better at stifling or reducing motion than innerspring models. However, the most efficient way to figure out the level of motion dampening is to test the mattresses yourself.

Thickness

Thickness of the mattress

It is easy to understand why the thickness of the mattress is very important. The reason is not far-fetched. The more pillow-like the top material of your mattress is, the more comfortable you will be. Thus, the thicker or denser the pillow top, the more comfortable the mattress will be. Simple as pie!

Firmness

Pillow tops are often employed to soften firmer beds. With that being said, pillow top mattresses should be a bit less firm than regular mattresses. It’s basically made to provide a great balancing feel between the softness of the pillow top and the push-back of the innerspring bed.

The most vital thing to take into consideration here is the support, of course. Your failure to choose the right pillow top mattress could lead to improper spinal alignment.

Certification

Ensure that the pillow top mattress you are picking comes with standard certifications like CertiPUR-US that confirms the use of eco-friendly and non-toxic materials in the manufacturing process of the mattress. It makes no sense to buy a pillow top to enhance the comfort and ease of your bed to the detriment of exposing yourself to harmful chemicals.

Warranty

Brand warranties vary according to the brand of the mattress. The most reputable brands offer warranties lasting up to 25 years and sometimes more. A high period of warranty speaks volume about the amount of confidence the company has in the quality of their mattress – it is a sign of the durability and longevity of the pillow.

Extra features

You also need to consider extra features such as trial period, package and cover material. One of the most vital things to consider when purchasing a mattress, particularly if you’re making your purchase online, is the trial period. It enables you to test out your new pillow top mattress for a stipulated period to see if it is sufficiently comfortable for you to get a restful night’s sleep.

FAQ

The CertiPUR-US® program certifies only flexible polyurethane foam for upholstered furniture and bedding products. Unfortunately, latex foam is outside the scope of CertiPUR-US certification.

The answer is natural latex. Natural latex ensures great ventilation to enable heat and moisture to dissipate, which helps you sleep cooler, healthier and more hygienically. However, memory foam is also considered a hypoallergenic material.

Normally, you should not feel the springs in your mattress while sleeping. However, when you start feeling the springs in your mattress, it is a big telling sign that your mattress is good as gone. It means it needs a replacement as soon as possible.

Pillow tops are likely the softest of all types of mattresses. But, while they offer a high comfort level, they sometimes have durability issues, and tend to sag and wear out faster.

Our Verdict

Our top-rated pillow top mattress is the Zinus Ultima Comfort 10 Inch Pillow Top Spring Mattress. This mattress comes with an iCoil system that is made up of numerous independent coils. This system takes away every issue related to motion transfer.

Our second pick is the Signature Sleep 13 inch Pillow-Top Mattress. It comes with a bamboo fiber cover which provides natural moisture absorbency and breathability, making it a decent fit for warmer temperatures.

Our third pick is the Classic Brands Mercer Pillow Top 12-Inch Mattress. Its thick foam layers offer enough comfort and support to every sleeper. Besides, it comes with infused gel which prevents your body from getting too warm and sweaty.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Pin It on Pinterest

Login/Register access is temporary disabled