Best Fireproof Safes

7 Best Fireproof Safes — Reviews and Buying Guide

31 Models Considered
58 Hours of Research
5 Experts Interviewed
252 Reviews Analyzed

Safes are a great way to prevent your valuables or important documents from being stolen. Of course, just a standard safe isn’t going to be all that helpful in the event of another kind of emergency, like a fire. No, for that, you need to be sure that you have the best fireproof safe possible. That way, you will be protected against burglary as well as any unexpected emergencies.

As you can imagine, there are several different factors that we had to consider when we were looking for the best fireproof safe for a home. To put together our list, we first looked at the capacity of each safe, as this will tell you how much you can store in it safely. Next, we looked into the overall dimensions of each model, since this information will be used to figure out where to place it. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, we looked into the different security systems each safe employs, as these systems are all that will stand between you and your valuables being lost and stolen.

Top 7 Fireproof Safes Review 2019

In order to put together our comprehensive list of the best home fireproof safes on the market, we spent tens of hours reading through hundreds of user reviews. That allowed us also to put together in-depth reviews of each model so that you can find the one that is right for you. Of course, if you are still not sure what to look for in your new safe, please take the time to read through our buying guide, which will tell you everything you need to know to find the best fireproof safe for your needs.

Image and Rating
Name and Features
Price
First Alert 2087F350
9.8
1. First Alert 2087F
Editor's Choice
Editor's Choice

This sturdy-made safe is both fire and waterproof; features a secure combination lock for your peace of mind

Steelwater AMSWD-500350
9.5
2. Steelwater AMSWD-500
Best Large Fireproof Safe
Best Large Fireproof Safe

A capacious safe that can withstand a whopping 2 hours at 1,850°F; has an inner drawer and a removable shelf

First Alert 2037F350
9.4
3. First Alert 2037F
Best Fireproof Safe for Files
Best Fireproof Safe for Files

An ideal safe to store your documents; has a 5-year warranty and is also waterproof as well

STEELMASTER Fire-Retardant Black Steel Security Box350
9.2
Best Fireproof Document Case

A small safe that is great to use for cash and documents; boasts of a steel construction with double-insulated walls

SentrySafe 1200 Fireproof Box350
9.0
Budget Pick

This affordable model will endure 30 minutes at 1,550°F; comes with a carrying handle and 2 keys

Honeywell 1106350
8.8
6. Honeywell 1106
Best Fire and Waterproof Safe
Best Fire and Waterproof Safe

A rather capacious safe which is not only fire but also water-resistant; backed by a lifetime after-fire replacement guarantee

Honeywell 6104350
8.6
7. Honeywell 6104
Easiest to Store
Easiest to Store

Being so small and compact, this unit is so simple to store even in the tiniest of houses; yet it’s capable of keeping all the important documents away from fire accidents

1.

First Alert 2087F Editor's Choice

Features
  • Capacity: 0.94 cu. ft.
  • Security system: combination lock; key lock
  • Endures: 1 hour at 1,700°F
  • Dimensions: 16.5 x 14.5 x 19 inches
  • Warranty: 5-year limited; lifetime after-fire replacement

More features: waterproof; ETL verified impact resistance

VIEW ON AMAZON

This just might be the best overall fireproof safe on the market today. One of the things that really stands out with this safe is its thick walls and insulation. This combination gives it one of the longest endurance ratings out there. It is capable of keeping your items intact for up to an hour at 1,700 degrees Fahrenheit. When you take into account that most structure fires only burn at 1,100 degrees, you can get a clearer picture as to the quality of this safe. Plain and simple, this safe will keep your things secure if a fire should occur in your home.

The company offers a five-year limited warranty should anything go wrong with the safe. While this warranty isn’t all that long, they also will replace your safe if you have a fire. This emergency warranty has no limit and is actually good for the lifetime of the product.

This safe is also very secure. It uses a combination lock and key to keep your documents and valuables from being tampered with. You just need to make sure that you take the time to memorize the combination carefully since it cannot be changed. Thankfully, the combination is not all that complex, so this shouldn’t be too difficult.

Not only is this safe fireproof, but it is also waterproof and impact resistant. Even if you accidentally drop it while you are moving it into position, you can rest assured that it will still keep your items safe and secure. The fact that it is waterproof helps to make it a great choice for anyone that lives near a body of water.

Pros
  • Lifetime after-fire replacement
  • Impact Resistant
  • Waterproof
  • Long endurance period
  • High-temperature rating
  • Works with combination lock or key
Cons
  • The combination cannot be changed

2.

Steelwater AMSWD-500 Best Large Fireproof Safe

Features
  • Capacity: 0.99 cu. ft.
  • Security system: combination lock; key lock
  • Endures: 2 hours at 1,850°F
  • Dimensions: 1.25 x 13.75 x 16.75 inches
  • Warranty: 1-year limited

More features: removable inner drawer; adjustable/removable shelf

VIEW ON AMAZON

When it comes to keeping your mementos, documents, and family treasures safe from a fire, you can never be too careful. If you are in the market for a safe that will go above and beyond to make sure that nothing happens to your things should a fire break out in your home, then this just might be the right option for you.

It has the highest fire rating available. In fact, it is rated to protect your items for up to two hours, even if the temperature should reach 1,850 degrees Fahrenheit. It will last for a much longer time if the temperature doesn’t get that high, making this an excellent option for anyone that wants as much of a guarantee as possible for their valuables to survive a fire.

Even though the combination cannot be altered on this model, you can rest assured that it will keep your items extremely safe. It also comes with a set of keys that can be used to unlock it as well. You just want to make sure that you keep these two keys in separate places so that you always have one if you need to use it.

This safe also has one of the largest capacities available, making it a great item for anyone that wants to stow away lots of things. It has an adjustable or removable shelf to help you keep organized. This shelf, along with the removable and easy-to-use drawer, helps to make this one of the best storage units on the market.

Pros
  • Adjustable and removable shelves
  • Inner drawer
  • Long endurance period
  • Extremely high-temperature rating
  • Very secure
Cons
  • Combination cannot be changed

3.

First Alert 2037F Best Fireproof Safe for Files

Features
  • Capacity: 0.62 cu. ft.
  • Security system: key lock
  • Endures: 30 minutes at 1,550°F
  • Dimensions: 26 x 30.9 x 21.8 inches
  • Warranty: 5-year limited; lifetime after-fire replacement

More features: holds standard file holders; waterproof

VIEW ON AMAZON

One of the most common things for people to keep in their fireproof safes are important files. These files might include marriage licenses, birth certificates, social security cards, or any other number of important papers. All of these papers can be quite difficult to keep in order in a regular firebox, but not with this model. It is built to organize standard file holders easily. This storage setup makes it a great option for anyone that wants to keep their important files, both safe and organized.

As you would imagine with a quality company like First Alert, this model comes with a lifetime guarantee that if you should experience a fire in your home, they will replace this safe free of charge. Not only does this reflect well on the company, but it shows that they stand behind their product, which is just one way that you can tell it is a quality safe.

This safe has a very high-temperature rating. Of course, it won’t last very long at that temperature, as it will only survive for about 30 minutes at 1,550 degrees. This should be plenty of time, however, considering most fires do not get that hot. This safe is also completely waterproof, so you can rest easy if your home is prone to flooding.

This safe is very easy to open and organize. While this is definitely a plus for you, it isn’t all that great if you experience a break-in. This safe is not meant to keep your documents secure against robbers, so you shouldn’t expect it to. Thankfully, it is small enough that you can keep it in a closet out of sight, which should help to keep it a bit safer if someone breaks into your home.

Pros
  • Lifetime replacement
  • High-temperature rating
  • Waterproof
  • Easy to open
  • Large capacity
Cons
  • Not very secure against break-ins

Features
  • Capacity: 0.17 cu. ft.
  • Security system: key lock
  • Endures: 15 minutes at 1,550°F
  • Dimensions: 12.25 x 8 x 3.75 inches
  • Warranty: not specified

More features: steel construction with double-insulated walls

VIEW ON AMAZON

As we have mentioned before, you can never be too careful when it comes to your important documents or valuables and fires. No matter where you are, no matter how new the structure is, and no matter how carefully you plan things out, fire can strike at any time. Which is why it is a good idea to have a portable fireproof safe handy.

This model, which is made by SteelMaster is a great example of a safe that would be a good choice for anyone that is in the process of moving or wants to keep their documents safe when they travel. This model is very lightweight and comes with an easy-to-use carrying handle that makes picking it up and taking it along a breeze.

Since this is such a lightweight and compact box, it should come as no surprise that it is perfect for storing pretty much anywhere in your home. This compact design helps to make it a great option for anyone that is staying in a new residence that hasn’t had a chance to get a bigger safe, as it can easily be stored wherever you want.

Even though this model is relatively small, it still has a very high heat rating. The one issue with this is that it, unfortunately, does not have a very long endurance period. This safe will only last for about 15 minutes at its maximum temperature. It is also not built to protect well against theft, as its locking mechanism could easily be broken, so keep that in mind before you make your final purchase.

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Portable
  • Fits in small spaces
  • High heat rating
Cons
  • Not very secure against break-ins
  • Very short endurance time

Features
  • Capacity: 0.18 cu. ft.
  • Security system: key lock
  • Endures: 30 minutes at 1,550°F
  • Dimensions: 14.3 x 11.2 x 6.1 inches
  • Warranty: 1-year limited

More features: comes with 2 keys; built-in carrying handle

VIEW ON AMAZON

When you hear the word safe, you probably think of something huge and expensive. You might even think that you can’t get good quality safe without spending tons of money. Thankfully, this is not the case, as long as you get this fireproof safe. This model is a high-quality firebox, that won’t cost you a ton of money to buy. Of course, it isn’t quite as durable as some of the more expensive models, but it will still offer plenty of fireproofing for the price. In fact, this safe can withstand 1,550 degrees for about half an hours, which should be plenty of protection for your paper documents.

If you do decide to buy this safe, you will want to make sure that you only use it for paper valuables. The reason for this is that, even though this safe can withstand 1,550 degrees externally, it will heat up to about 400 degrees internally. This temperature, while not dangerous for papers, could melt plastics and some metals. This safe would not be a good option for data storage because of this reason.

This is one of the easier to carry safes on the market today. It is designed to be used very much like a briefcase, complete with easy to use handle. The exterior is very durable, which will help to protect it against any drops, bumps, or dings that might happen.

Pros
  • Budget-friendly
  • High heat rating
  • Very portable
  • Easy to open
  • Easily fits in small spaces
Cons
  • Only good for paper storage

6.

Honeywell 1106 Best Fire and Waterproof Safe

Features
  • Capacity: 0.64 cu. ft.
  • Security system: key lock
  • Endures: 30 minutes at 1,550°F
  • Dimensions: 15.7 x 16.9 x 12.8 inches
  • Warranty: 7-year limited; lifetime after-fire replacement

More features: waterproof

VIEW ON AMAZON

Though fire is usually on everyone’s list as the worst thing that could happen to their home, water damage can be just as devastating. If water gets into your home, it can destroy things just as badly as a fire can, and can turn your once-lovely home into an unlivable mess. Water is just as dangerous to documents and precious mementos as fire, so if you live near any body of water, it only makes sense to look for a fire and waterproof safe. If that is your situation, then you this may be the right model for you.

Not only is this model rated for 30 minutes at 1,550 degrees, but it is also completely waterproof. Even if this safe is completely submerged for a short period of time, your documents will be safe and sound, regardless of whether you are storing paper or electronic items.

This safe also has a large capacity that helps to make it a great option for storing larger items, such as external hard drives full of family memories or even whole photo albums. The case is very easy to open and is wide enough to fit larger items nicely.

The only thing that you will need to keep in mind with this safe is that the locking mechanism is very easy to break. You need to be sure to keep it completely clear when you are closing the safe, or you might accidentally bend it.

Pros
  • Lifetime after-fire replacement
  • High heat rating
  • Large capacity
  • Waterproof
Cons
  • Flimsy locking mechanism

7.

Honeywell 6104 Easiest to Store

Features
  • Capacity: 0.17 cu. ft.
  • Security system: key lock
  • Endures: 20 minutes at 400°F
  • Dimensions: 3.9 x 12.7 x 9.0 inches
  • Warranty: 1-year limited

More features: comes with 2 entry keys

VIEW ON AMAZON

Lots of times when you are looking at safes, it can be very difficult to find one that will fit into your home, especially if you live in an apartment. Many models are simply too bulky to fit into the living space that you have, much less slide into a closet with ease. This model, on the other hand, is nice and slim, making it an ideal choice for anyone has a limited amount of space to store a safe. While this safe is definitely very slim, it is still more than big enough to fit all of your important documents.

It should come as no surprise that such a slim case is also very easy to move from place to place. Even if you load this fire case down with as many items as possible, you shouldn’t have any issue moving it around. The secure lock and easy carry handle help to make moving this safe very easy.

This case is not really designed to keep your items secure from anything but a fire. Even though the lock is strong enough to hold the case shut, it could easily be opened. It does come with an extra key, which is a good backup if you should accidentally lose the first one.

Something that you will want to keep in mind with this particular case is that it has a very low-temperature rating. This case is only rated to about 400 degrees for a short amount of time. It would keep your documents safe in the event of a minor fire, but would not do very well in the case of a full-scale blaze.

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Portable
  • Easy to fit in small spaces
  • Comes with extra key
Cons
  • Low temperature rating

Buying Guide

In this section, we will go through everything you need to know to find the best fireproof safe to keep your valuables secure. We have also taken the time to answer several frequently asked questions, so be sure to read through those as well if you are still unsure about anything.

Why opt for a fireproof safe

7 Best Fireproof Safes — Reviews and Buying GuideThere are many different reasons that you should pick fireproof safe for your home. These include:

  • Protection Against the Burglary – If you have valuables in your home, such as cash, jewelry, or family heirlooms, then the last thing you want to do is have them simply stashed in a closet. If you should be so unfortunate as to have your home broken into by a robber, a fireproof safe is going to keep your valuables safe from being stolen.
  • Fireproof – As the name suggests, these safes are fireproof. Everyone has home insurance, but that will only cover you so far in the case of a fire emergency in your home. Though insurance might replace your home, it can never replace family memories, important documents, or precious valuables. A fireproof safe can help to give you peace of mind just in case the unimaginable becomes a reality.
  • Waterproof – Some, but not all, fireproof safes are also waterproof. This is a great feature since emergencies aren’t just limited to fires. This is especially true if you live near a river, stream, or creek. A waterproof safe, like the First Alert 2037F, is a great system to help protect your important documents in any type of emergency.
  • Heavyweight – One of the reasons that fireproof safes are such a good option for helping to prevent theft is that they are quite heavy. Since they need to have extra layers built in to make them fireproof, these safes can weigh well over a hundred pounds. This hefty weight makes them much more difficult for a burglar to pick up and take away with them during a break-in.
  • Durable – As you would expect from a safe that weighs so much, these safes are exceedingly durable. Whichever one you choose to buy, you can rest assured that it is going to last a good long time. The materials used to make them fireproof also help to make them last for years to come, making your purchase a sound investment in securing your valuables.
  • Convenient – The only other way that you can make sure that your important documents, like your passport, birth certificate, marriage license, etc. are safe from emergencies is to keep them somewhere else. The problem with this system, of course, is that they are not in a convenient spot if you need them. By getting a fireproof safe, you can keep your documents safe, and within easy reach should you need to access them.

Features to consider while choosing a fireproof safe

Capacity

The first thing that you are going to want to consider when it comes to finding your fireproof safe is the capacity. The capacity of the safe is going to determine how many items you can fit into it, and the types of items that you can store within it. The best idea when buying a fireproof safe is to get one that can handle more than you intend to store in it right away. The last thing that you want to do is to limit what you can store in it since you will probably acquire more valuables and more important documents during your life after you purchase your safe.

If you are looking for the largest safe on the market, then the Steelwater AMSWD-500 is going to be the best option. It has plenty of room for valuables, as well as enough space for plenty of documents, even if you have a ton to store. On the other hand, if you are looking to save a bit of money and don’t need to store a lot of stuff, then the Honeywell 6104 might be a good choice.

Security system

7 Best Fireproof Safes — Reviews and Buying GuideThe security system that your new safe employs will have a direct effect on how secure it is should you experience a break-in at your residence. There are three basic systems that you can choose from in this regard. They are:

  • Lock and Key – This is the simplest system for securing your things, which also means that it is the easiest to break into. It operates much like a door on your house, in that it uses a key to unlock and open the safe. Of course, you need to be sure that you keep the key in a secure spot, or there is no way for you to get into your safe.
  • Combination Lock – If you picture any safe that you have seen in a movie or show, a combination lock is going to be what comes to mind. It involves a dial that needs to be turned to the correct sequence of numbers in order to unlock the safe. This makes it extremely secure. Thankfully, if you should forget the combination, lots of safes with combination locks, like the First Alert 2087F, come with a key as well.
  • Digital Keypad – Digital keypads are much like combination locks, except they instead of turning a dial, all you need to do is punch in the code. These locks will need the batteries to be changed every so often, so that is an additional cost. Much like a combination lock safe, many of these models also come with a key in case you forget the combination.

What temperature it can withstand and for how long

When it comes to a fireproof safe, you want to be sure that it is actually fireproof and not simply fire-resistant.

If you get a safe that is only fire-resistant, then your documents won’t last very long if they are exposed to high temperatures for a long period of time. The best idea is to get a safe that has the highest temperature and time rating possible.

Let’s be honest; firefighters are not going to be searching through your home for a safe while they are fighting the fire and trying to get your loved ones to safety. By getting a safe with a high temperature and time duration rating, you will help to make sure that your items are that much safer. If that is what you are looking for, then the Steelwater AMSWD-500 just might be the right safe for you. It can last for a total of two hours at a temperature of 1,800 degrees. This should give your valuable items enough protection during the time that the firefighters are working to extinguish the flames.

Materials used

7 Best Fireproof Safes — Reviews and Buying GuideThe materials used in fire safes are generally very similar across the board. These safes usually have a combination of steel and insulation to help protect your items from being burned or damaged by water. The thing that helps to determine how fireproof your new safe will be is how thick these materials are.

If you look at a smaller safe, like the Honeywell 6104, it shouldn’t come as a big surprise that it doesn’t have the highest temperature or time rating. The insulation and steel are both relatively thin, making this a nice and lightweight safe, which will offer minimal security in the event of a fire. On the other hand, the First Alert 2087F has thick steel and insulation, giving it a much longer endurance time at higher temperatures. Of course, this does make it a heavier safe, so don’t expect to move it around too often once you have it in place.

External dimensions

Once you have determined the capacity you need, as well as the heat rating you want to keep your items secure, then you should carefully plan where you are going to keep your new safe. The external dimensions of the different safes on the market are something that you will want to keep in mind after you have determined where you will keep it in your home. Obviously, if you have a smaller space, then you are going to need to make sure that you get a smaller safe. If space isn’t an issue, then you can go ahead and purchase any size safe.

One of the most common places that people like to keep their safes is in a closet in their bedroom. Even more common, is keeping it on a high shelf in said closet. If that is the case for you and your family, then the SentrySafe 1200 Fireproof Box might be a good option. It is almost the size of an undersized briefcase, which allows it to fit onto smaller shelves or tight spaces easily.

Warranty

Any time you buy anything that is designed to keep your items safe, you want to make sure that it is backed by a warranty. Though the hope is that you don’t ever have to use the warranty to replace any part of your new safe, it is nice to know that the company stands behind their product. Some of these safes are also quite an investment, so a warranty is an extra protection to make sure that you don’t lose any money if something should fail on the safe through its normal use.

Something else to keep in mind with these safes is since they are designed to be used in a fire, some companies will offer lifetime replacements should a fire occur. This, as we mentioned before, is a great way for a company to show that they stand behind their product. This lifetime guarantee also helps to make your purchase that much more of a value.

Extra features

As we said previously, safes are relatively straightforward devices. They are designed to keep your things sealed up and safe from fire and not much else. Of course, there are still some extra features that might make your life a bit easier. One of the best things to keep in mind, especially if you have a lot to store, are removable or adjustable shelves. These shelves will make getting all of your documents and valuables into the safe that much easier.

Something else that you might want to keep in mind, especially if you live near a body of water, is getting a safe that is waterproof. If you do get a waterproof safe, your documents will be protected against more than just fire or break-ins, making it an even better investment in the security of your things.

Finally, if you get a safe that can only be opened by a key, it might be a good idea to get one that comes with an extra set. That way, should you accidentally lose the first set of keys, you will have a backup so that you can still get into your safe.

How to maintain your safe

7 Best Fireproof Safes — Reviews and Buying GuideThough these safes are designed to withstand staggering amounts of heat, that doesn’t mean that they are indestructible. There are several different things that you can do every once in a while to help make sure that your safe is functioning properly. If you don’t take the time to maintain your safe, you run the risk of it failing in the case of an emergency, so be sure to take some time each month to monitor the following:

  • Battery Maintenance – If you purchase a safe that has a digital keypad, you will want to keep a close eye on the battery levels. Otherwise, you run the risk of the battery losing power on you, which makes opening the safe a lot more difficult.
  • Moisture Control – Even if you get a waterproof safe, repeated exposure to moisture is eventually going to wear down the hinges and exterior of the safe. This could limit its effectiveness during a fire or flood since rust will make it much easier for these dangerous elements to enter into your safe and destroy your things.
  • Cleaning the Surface and Interior – Since these safes are designed to be used for years and years, it is best to make sure that you keep them free of dust, dirt, and grime, on both the interior and exterior. You should also always make sure that your hands are clean when you are using your safe so that your important documents don’t get any dirt or grime on them when you open the safe up. A gentle cleaner is all you need to use to keep the safe looking like it just came off the shelf.

FAQ

If you live near a body of water, it is not a question of if it will flood, but simply a question of when. In that case, it is best to look for a waterproof as well as fireproof safe. Out of the models on our list, the following are waterproof:

Accidents are prone to happen. If you should accidentally drop your safe while you are moving it, the first thing that you will want to do is open it up to make sure that everything works correctly. Since these safes are made to protect your valuables in extreme conditions, the odds are that it won’t have suffered any damage. This is especially the case if you get a safe like the First Alert 2087F, which is designed to be impact resistant.

If you should lose the key that came with your safe, all you need to do is contact the company that made it. Be sure that you have the model number handy since they will need that to send you a new key.

Our Verdict

Of all the different safes that we looked into, the First Alert 2087F is by far the best. It has one of the largest capacities on the market and has an outstanding temperature and time rating. It is also very secure, making it a great option to not only protect your documents against fire but theft as well.

If you have a ton of things that you want to keep in your fire safe, then the Steelwater AMSWD-500 is a great choice. It is large enough to accommodate all of your valuables and even comes with an adjustable shelf and drawer. It also has the best fire rating on the market, which means it will keep your things safe and secure.

Important papers are the most common thing that people want to keep in their fire safe. As such, the First Alert 2037F is the best fireproof safe around. It is designed to be used with file folders, which makes keeping your things organized super simple.

9.8/10 Total Score
First Alert 2087F - Editor's Choice
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      Pin It on Pinterest

      Login/Register access is temporary disabled